Mutual Fund SIP vs Stock SIP: Which is consistent?

SIP investments have brought a revolution in the way Indians invest, as this has enabled Indians to invest in a disciplined and regular manner. Although the term SIP investment has traditionally referred to investing in mutual funds periodically, with the dynamically changing environment, Indian investors also have the option of making SIP investments in individual stocks, which has resulted in the emergence of the following question:
Which SIP investment option provides better returns?
Therefore, it becomes essential to understand the differences between these SIP investments to choose the right SIP process that is more suitable according to an individual's financial goals. In this blog, we will explore mutual fund SIP vs stock SIP on the grounds of consistency, risk, and returns.
What are mutual fund SIPs?
A mutual fund SIP is a systematic way of investing a fixed amount of money in a mutual fund scheme at regular intervals of time, which can be on a monthly, quarterly, or yearly basis. The investment is made at the prevailing Net Asset Value (NAV) of the mutual fund regardless of the market situation. This strategy eventually helps to average out the cost of investment for the investors through rupee cost averaging.
A mutual fund scheme pools money from several investors, which is then invested in a variety of instruments to create a diversified portfolio and is managed by a professional fund manager. Thus, when an investor invests via SIP, they are buying into that diversified basket of securities.
The mutual funds that investors invest in are managed by professional fund managers who, on behalf of investors, review and manage the mutual funds' allocation by carrying out all the market research, trend analysis, and then adjusting the portfolio.
Use the SIP Calculator to estimate your returns in seconds.
What are stock SIPs?
Stock SIPs refer to the investment of a fixed amount directly in the shares of individual companies regularly, which can be monthly, quarterly, or yearly. Many new platforms, like Dhan, allow investors to set up automatic recurring purchases of specific stocks at regular intervals. With stock SIPs, investors are buying fractional or whole shares of one company at a time.
By investing a fixed amount periodically in stock SIPs, investors aim to average their buying cost over time.
In stock SIPs, investors are solely responsible for research, company selection, and portfolio monitoring. There isn't any professional fund manager who will be making decisions or rebalancing their holdings on their behalf, as in mutual fund investments.
Comparison between mutual fund and stock SIPs?
While both are SIP investments, they are similar in many aspects, but their differences make them unique, catering to different investors' needs. A comparison between some key factors of mutual fund SIP vs stock SIP is discussed below:
Consistency
Mutual fund SIPs often offer more consistent performance due to diversification. A diversified equity fund may hold 50-100 stocks spanning across several sectors.
Thus, even when some of the companies underperform, others may compensate, therefore smoothing out the overall returns. It is this diversification that buffers against company-specific risks.
In contrast, stock SIPs are much more volatile, with less predictable returns. The performance of the entire investment hinges on the fortunes of a single company. If investors have chosen the right stock and the company grows substantially, then stock SIP returns can far exceed mutual fund SIP performance. But if the company faces difficulties like poor management or technological disruption, the investor's entire investment takes a hit.
In other words, the concentration risk in stock SIPs would imply that the returns could vary from spectacular gains to a complete loss; thus, the stock SIPs investment consistency is inherently lower compared to diversified mutual fund SIPs.
Risk management
Risk management is the most important factor that distinguishes the two SIP investment methods. The mutual fund SIP involves diversifying the risk across multiple securities. This implies that if a particular company becomes bankrupt or underperforms, the impact may be minimal since that particular stock would only constitute a small fraction of the whole portfolio, and the overall investment returns would not be much affected.
On the other hand, stock SIPs have undiversified risk. A single mistake while selecting the stock will adversely affect the whole portfolio. All incidents related to a company, such as fraudulent accounting, resignation of top management, failed products, and lawsuits, directly impact the whole portfolio that is invested in the stock of that particular company.
Returns potential
Though mutual funds SIPs ensure consistency, stock SIPs have a higher potential for returns for skilled investors who are willing to take a risk for high returns. As well-chosen individual stocks can deliver multibagger returns, increasing 10x, 20x, or even higher over the long term. For example, long-term SIPs initiated by early investors who invested in stocks of companies like HDFC, Asian Paints, or Titan have generated immense wealth, going beyond the returns generated by mutual funds.
However, such outperformance calls for extremely adept stock selection skills, patience, and often some luck. Most individual investors underperform the market and mutual fund benchmarks due to poor timing, emotional decisions, and a lack of research.
The returns on mutual fund SIPs tend to be similar to the market returns or slightly better. For example, index funds provide returns equal to their benchmark index, reduced by a small expense ratio. The primary benefit of mutual fund SIPs is that they provide professional management and research expertise that would not be available with stock SIPs.
Which is better?
Whether to choose Mutual Fund SIPs or Stock SIPs is decided on the following factors:
Invest in mutual fund SIPs if you are :
- An investor who has no investment background or prior experience in investments.
- Performing research regularly is not possible for you due to time constraints.
- You would like your investments to be handled by professionals.
- You want the diversification of investment exposure in a single investment vehicle.
- You would like to have consistent long-term returns.
Invest in stock SIPs if you are:
- Investors with strong financial knowledge and analytical skills.
- Has the capacity to spend time researching and tracking individual companies.
- Higher risk tolerance and longer investment horizons.
- Can take big bets on well-researched companies.
With the ever-changing world of finance, many savvy investors have taken a hybrid approach, one that combines the best of both worlds. With a hybrid approach, the investors invest more in diverse mutual funds for assured growth and stability and less in a Stock SIP for high-belief bets. This strategy enables them to capture the market-aligned returns through mutual funds and achieve the alpha returns through well-researched individual stocks.
The final call
Ultimately, the purpose of investing is to meet financial goals. While Mutual Fund SIPs tend to offer a more consistent and less volatile journey to investment due to their diversified nature and professional management, Stock SIPs have the potential to offer better returns at the expense of increased risk and an investment of significant personal research and monitoring.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I hold simultaneous investments in a Mutual Fund SIP and a Stock SIP?
Yes, one can invest in both Mutual Fund SIPs and Stock SIPs. A large number of investors are adopting the Core-Satellite Investing strategy, where mutual fund SIPs are used as the core investments with the aim of diversification and bringing stability within the portfolio. Stock SIPs are satellites that have the goal of generating maximum returns on selected stocks. Thus, this helps balance consistency and an increased growth potential.
What is the initial investment required in a mutual fund SIP and a stock SIP?
A mutual fund SIP can be started with as little as Rs. 100 per month, hence making them easily accessible to a beginner investor with small funds. At the same time, a stock SIP would be dependent on the price per stock that the individual wishes to buy. If the stock price costs ₹1,000 or more per share, then a minimum of ₹ 1,000 or more per instalment would have to be put into a stock SIP.
Do stock SIPs provide better tax advantages than mutual fund SIPs?
From a taxation perspective, both stock SIPs and equity mutual fund SIPs are treated similarly. Both equity mutual funds and individual stocks held for more than one year attract long-term capital gains (LTCG) tax at 12.5% on gains over ₹1.25 lakhs every year. For investments held for less than one year, they attract Short Term Capital Gains (STCG) tax at 20%. For dividend earnings on shares as well as mutual funds held through SIPs, they get added to the tax liability and taxed based on the tax bracket of the investor.
Which is safer, a Mutual Fund SIP or a Stock SIP?
A mutual fund-based SIP often involves less risk compared to a stock SIP. The reason is that in the case of a mutual fund-based SIP, the investment is made in different companies. This reduces the likelihood of any single stock pulling down the performance of the overall portfolio. In contrast, a stock SIP is a concentrated bet, and if the selected stock underperforms or faces any business problem, the overall portfolio return will be adversely impacted. The mutual fund-based SIPs are thus beneficial in managing risk.
Which SIP is better during market volatility?
In times of market fluctuations, mutual fund SIPs relatively perform better than stock SIPs due to diversification and professional management.











